LogoLogo
  • SHx
    • SHx Whitepaper
    • SHx Governance Rules
  • ECOSYSTEM
    • EDP
      • Ecosystem Grants
      • Bounties
      • General Eligibility
  • Governance
    • Account Voting Power
    • Proposals
      • 1 - MCA Origination Fee Burn
      • 2 - Establishing a Public Governance Venue and Voting Proxy
      • 3 - Opening Access to StrongholdNET
      • 4 - Adoption of Proposed SHx Governance Rules
      • 5 - Recording of Votes in a Smart Contract
    • Voting Process
      • Stellar
      • Ethereum
  • Community
    • SHx Community Guidelines
    • Discord
  • Stronghold Links
    • Website
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
    • LinkedIn
Powered by GitBook

© Stronghold 2017 - 2024. All rights reserved.

On this page
  • Description
  • Background
  • Voting Notes
  • Results

Was this helpful?

  1. Governance
  2. Proposals

5 - Recording of Votes in a Smart Contract

This proposal asks whether SHx governance votes from all ledgers (Stellar & Ethereum) be recorded in a smart contract on the Stellar ledger.

Last updated 24 days ago

Was this helpful?

Outcome: FOR. ​The adoption of the SHx Governance Snapshot unifies all SHx governance votes—from both Stellar and Ethereum—under a single smart contract on the Stellar network.

Event
Date
Notes

Snapshot Time

Mar 12, 2024 20:00 GMT

Ledger Sequences

Stellar: 56,121,374

Vote Start

Mar 17, 2024 20:00 GMT

First included Stellar ledger: 56,197,285

Vote End

Mar 21, 2024 20:00 GMT

Last included Stellar ledger: 56,256,292

Results Published

Apr 2, 2024 20:00 GMT

Implementation

Q2 2025

Description

in Article V of the SHx Governance Rules currently specify separate methods for recording votes on the Stellar and Ethereum ledgers. With Soroban functionality now stable and available, SHx votes can be recorded in smart contracts rather than as transactions on the Stellar chain or through Snapshot.org for Ethereum. This transition will enhance the capabilities of the SHx governance application through expanded smart contract functionality.

This proposal seeks to consolidate the recording of votes from all ledgers into a single smart contract deployed on Soroban, replacing Article V Section 2 entirely. Specific implementation details will be developed following approval of this proposal.

Background

Following the successful launch of Stellar's Soroban smart contracts platform, Stronghold is developing additional Stellar-based smart contract functionality for the SHx ecosystem. These developments include treasury escrows and the proposed voting record system (with snapshots being considered contingent on this proposal's passage).

Regardless of this vote's outcome, Stronghold will enhance the SHx voting portal to create a comprehensive governance hub. This hub will facilitate voting, provide access to historical vote information, and connect to SHx-related smart contracts such as escrows for easier inspection.

Consolidating votes from all ledgers (Stellar, Ethereum, and any future blockchain integrations) into a Stellar-based smart contract would streamline voting operations. This approach would simplify development of additional voting tools, vote counting mechanisms, and other governance applications. The current system—relying on Snapshot for Ethereum and transaction-based voting for Stellar—presents integration challenges and lacks the elegance and functionality of a dedicated smart contract solution.

Voting Notes

The vote asks whether SHx governance votes from all ledgers (Stellar & Ethereum) be recorded in a smart contract on the Stellar ledger.

As a Governance Rules amendment, this proposal requires a two-thirds (2/3) super-majority and a quorum of 25% of the active circulating supply to pass. If necessary, Stronghold will vote in alignment with the simple majority's preference to help implement the community's desired outcome.


Results

A total of 78,808,031 voting power participated in the proposal vote.

Question

Should SHx gov votes from all ledgers (Stellar & Ethereum) be recorded in a smart contract on the Stellar ledger?

Response
Position
Votes

FOR

The adoption of the SHx Governance Snapshot unifies all SHx governance votes—from both Stellar and Ethereum—under a single smart contract on the Stellar network.

77,148,850

AGAINST

The proposal to record all SHx votes on Stellar smart contracts should not be adopted as the sole voting mechanism for SHx governance.

0

ABSTAIN

Abstain from voting for this proposal.

1,659,181

Outcome: FOR. ​The adoption of the SHx Governance Snapshot unifies all SHx governance votes—from both Stellar and Ethereum—under a single smart contract on the Stellar network.

Section 2a: Stellar Voting Process